home
Film review by Colin Fraser

YOURS, MINE AND OURS

yoursmineours
An artist with eight children marries a naval officer with ten - but no one's laughing. score

1
moviereview rates films from
1 (unwatchable) to 5 (unmissable)
FIND A MOVIEREVIEW
Cast
Dennis Quaid, Rene Russo, Sean Faris, Drake Bell

Director
Raja Gosnell

Screenwriter
Ron Birch, David Kidd

Country
USA

Rating / Running Time
PG / 90 minutes

Australian Release
March 2006

Official Site




(c) moviereview 2006
ABN 72 775 390 361

Yours, Mine and Ours updates the 1968 original starring Lucille Ball and Henry Fonda. Based loosely on a book, it also arrived as something of an update to Cheaper by the Dozen, which itself has been updated twice since. The point being, in a world of depleted originality, the current Yours, Mine and Ours is a masterwork of uncreativity.

Rene Russo and Dennis Quaid take the reigns as former lovers who have a second chance at marriage and will bring with them enough children for a football team. Naturally, the parenting styles differ; Frank is a career naval officer, Helen is a designer who firmly believes that ‘homes are for free expression, not good impressions’. Translated, her kids are brats while his could teach the Von Trapp’s a thing or two about posture. Cue dysfunctional mayhem as the two halves fail to make a whole, and the kids hatch a plan to save themselves by splitting their parents. How children have changed in forty years.

There’s a spark of interest generated between Russo and Quaid. In fact, had they left the kids at home and cultivated the romantic comedy potential, this might have been half-good. Instead we get a shrill episode of The Brady Bunch meets Family Feud and it’s all bad. A measure of just how excruciating things become is illustrated in the film’s funniest moment – Frank cleans his teeth. It’s what you should expect when the director of Scooby Doo: 2 and  Home Alone: 3 gets to work a screenplay by the writer of Head Over Heels. Even ten year olds will struggle with this dull-witted, formulaic exercise.

// COLIN FRASER