
![]() |
An epic drama of a young Indian boy who escapes poverty to become a successfull merchant. But can he escape a love forged in childhood? | score B- |
moviereview rates films from A (unmissable) to E (unwatchable) |
| FIND A MOVIEREVIEW |
| Cast Tanishta Chatterjee, Irfan Khan, Prashant Narayanan Director Florian Gallenberger Screenwriter Florian Gallenberger Country India / Germany (subtitles) Rating / Running Time M / 122 minutes Australian Release December 2005 Official Site (c) moviereview
2005
ABN 72 775 390 361 |
When old men lovingly caress worn objects
(in this case, a disused factory), it’s usually an opener to flashback. And lo,
sixty years ago the emotional man is a boy once again, working in a woollen
mill outside Calcutta. This sweat-shop is also a depository in which poor
families rid themselves of unwanted children. Girls like recent arrival Masha
whom the young Ravi befriends. Smitten, they make a pact to reunite when they
finally take leave of the factory but, of course, fate intervenes and their destiny
is clouded. There’s a Hollywood sensibility to the production that reflects the
perspective of a German director in India. He asks us to consider the
foreigner’s tradition, Scorsese’s Kundun
for example, in this regard. And to be fair, Shadows Of Time does a good job of keeping its feet planted on both
sides of the cultural divide. Florian Gallenberger’s production is elegantly
crafted and beautifully acted: there’s an echo of Deepa Mehta in early scenes,
those that work best. He manages to shock us into sobriety with the gruesome
reality of child labour and prostitution; particularly as he lets us forget
(temporarily) which decade we’re in. As the story evolves – Ravi becomes a
successful merchant, Masha marries well - it emerges that this is largely a
romantic drama with interests that lie in the emotional, not social, context:
guilt, suffering, fortune. Providence is at the key of this billowing drama and
it’s here that Shadows of Time will
either sweep you away, or leave you wanting. It rests entirely on your taste
for fatalism, culturally observant as that may be. A dangerous position nonetheless,
one that often leads to old men caressing worn objects. // COLIN FRASER |