Saul's daughter stands a good chance at the spelling champs, an occasion that lifts the lid on his family's dysfunction. | score 2+ |
moviereview rates films from 5 (unmissable) to 1 (unwatchable) |
|
FIND A MOVIEREVIEW |
Cast Richard Gere, Flora Cross, Juliette Binoche, Max Minghella Director Scott McGhee, David Siegel Screenwriter Naomi Foner Gyllenhaal Country USA Rating / Running Time M / 103 minutes Australian Release November 2005 Official Site (c) moviereview
2005
ABN 72 775 390 361 |
Saul is the domineering head of an upper middle-class American family. He lectures in theology and practices violin with his teenage son. His daughter has a gift for spelling, his wife – well, we’re not too sure about his wife. Such is the introduction to Naomi Gyllenhaal’s (Running On Empty) lid-lifting examination of family dynamics. Even those who seem to have it all, she suggests, often don’t. Poor Richard Gere, whose
determination to run the family unit runs him into a brick wall when his
spiritually empty son takes up with the Krishnas and the marbles of his wife
(Juliette Binoche) are found wanting. He barely notices since his daughter’s
spelling prowess has led him to question whether she has the ear of God. This
handsome production is rich in allegory and cinematic iconography. It’s a
pleasure to look at and enjoyable to spend time with a reasonably functional,
if overly serious, family. Here are people who respect one another and can
speak in fully formed sentences. “Words hold their history in their letters,”
teaches Pop. Delivered with some visual aplomb by directing partners Scott
McGehee and David Siegel, Bee Season
is a curious affair. It’s the kind of film you want to like much more than you
can. The plight of their characters should earn our sympathy yet so stodgy is
their direction that the story’s emotional heart fails to make much of an
impression. Many great ideas, given a lighter touch, could have flown instead
of simply buzzing around the edges of possibility. Nonetheless, Binoche is
pretty to watch, as is the potential of her on-screen daughter, Flora Cross. // COLIN FRASER |